Compare · macOS and Windows

Superscreen vs Camtasia.

The training-video standard. Templates, quizzes, asset libraries and an editor built for lessons rather than clips.

All comparisons

Subscription, from about $179 a year

Matches 13 of 16 features

The honest read

Where Camtasia is the better answer, and where it is not.

What Camtasia does well

Templates and stock assets that make a twenty-video course look consistent.
The same project opens on Windows, which matters on a mixed team.
Interactivity and quizzing that nothing else here attempts.

Where it runs out of road

Subscription only, at a price aimed at training departments.
Slow to start and slow to export next to a native capture tool.
Enormous surface area for someone who wanted to record a window.

Camtasia is aimed at a team producing curriculum, and it is good at that. Superscreen is aimed at the recording itself, priced for one person, and finished before Camtasia has drawn its timeline.

Feature by feature

The whole list, both ways.

Every row opens that feature in full, with the panel that shows it running.

Every Superscreen feature, against Camtasia
Feature	Superscreen	Camtasia
CountdownThree seconds before the first frame	Included	Included
Frame rateSixty for motion, thirty for size	Included	Included
QualityHalf the file, the same picture	Included	Included
CursorKeep the pointer in or out	Included	Included
Click highlightsA ring blooms at every click	Included	Included
Camera bubbleA round camera in any corner	Included	Included
AudioYour voice and the Mac, separately	Included	Included
Trim and cutTrim the ends, cut the middle	Included	Included
AssetsDrop in sounds, images and screens	Included	Included
CaptionsSubtitles written on the device	Included	Included
KeystrokesShortcuts drawn as real keycaps	Included	Included
Export formatsExport .mov, .mp4, .webm or .gif	Included	Included
PerformanceA few percent of one core	Included	Not included
File namesTemplates that sort recordings for you	Included	Partly
Cursor zoomZoom that follows the cursor	Included	Partly
ProjectsEvery recording in one library	Included	Included

IncludedIncluded
PartlyPartly
Not includedNot included

Checked August 2026. Prices and features move — worth a look at the source before you decide.